ORION Sub Challenge Test Results  

powered byAt Orion Car Audio, we know that if you want to BE the best, you have to BEAT the best, so we decided to put that motto to the test by placing the Orion HCCA Subwoofer head-to-head with its closest competition. To see videos of the Subwoofer Challenge, click sub images below. We took great pains to make sure that the test is both fair and easy to repeat.

In fact, we are keeping the challenge going by laying out our test methodology and challenging our competitors to try the same test and see if they get the same results. May the best woofer win – and in our tests that was the Orion HCCA!

Test Methodology:

 

Testing was conducted by a neutral third-party: Syndicate Automotive Concepts in San Diego, a leader in the vehicle customization business.

syndicate
















Cliff and his team have been building show-stopping, award-winning rides for their VIP clientele for over 15 years.

Identical Crown I-T8000 power supplies were used, along with identical Fluke 87 multimeters to monitor voltage.

All the enclosures were sealed and built to the manufacturers optimal performance specifications.

test equipment

The Orion HCCA Challenge consisted of our 12” Orion HCCA Subwoofer vs. 5 leading competitors’ subwoofers.

See the Videos!
JL Audio W7
JL Audio sub
MTX 9500
mtx sub
Rockford Fosgate T1
rockford fosgate sub
KickerSoloX
kicker sub
Cerwin-VegaStroker
cerwin vega sub

 

Here are their respective stats:

 

Brand
MTX
Rockford Fosgate
JL Audio
Kicker
Cerwin-Vega
Orion
Model
9500
T1
W7
SoloX
Stroker
HCCA
Airspace
1.5 cf
1.25 cf
1.375 cf
1.5 cf
.9 cf
RMS
1,000 w
600 w
750 w
2,500 w
2,000 w
2,000 w
Peak
2,000 w
1,200 w
1,500 w
5,000 w
4,000 w
4,000 w

 

The Test was designed to simulate real world usage. Test tones are for engineers. Music is for hardcore enthusiasts.test equipment The signal used must be clean, with no distortion or clipping - the same bass track was utilized throughout the test.

The enclosures were sealed and were built to the manufacturers’ recommended size. All power tests were based on Re of voice coil or nominal impedance. 

All testing was completed with the subwoofers in the enclosures:  The Orion Test box is sealed w/ .9 cu. ft of airspace.

Matching Fluke 87 multimeters were used to read and verify peaks in RMS Voltage.



Test Steps:



  1. Step 1 -Break-In
    1 hour at 1000 RMS with 30 Hz test tone or 2000 Peak Music Power from test disk to break-in the speaker.

  2. Step 2 - Begin Peak Music Test
    1 hour at 3000 W Peak Music Power.  Monitor the speaker performance during the test. Once Step 2 is begun the speaker should not be given any prolonged rest or cool down time until the Step 2 is completely finished or the woofer fails.

  3. Step 3 thru 13 - Continue Test
    At the end of each hour let the test speaker rest for 30 minutes then increase power in 500 W RMS increments.  During the rest period the woofer should be visually examined for any failures or problems during this pause.
Test Results:

 

Brand

Series

Peak Music Power Max Wattage

Total Time

Failure Mode

Orion

HCCA

6050

1hr 30min

Thermal

Rockford

Power

2983.78

3 min

mechanical

Cerwin- Vega

Stroker

2983.78

5 min

Thermal

JL

W7

3072

7 min

mechanical

MTX

Thunder

3494.8

1hr 5min

mechanical

Kicker

SoloX

3499.91

1hr 12min

mechanical

At the conclusion of the test, after all the competing woofers had failed, we decided to test the HCCA to destruction – which finally occurred at over 6,000 watts – 2,000 watts above rated peak.

KIDS, DON’T TRY THIS AT HOME!

Summary:

 

We encourage our competitors to take the HCCA Challenge!

Want to know more about the Orion HCCA Subwoofer?
Go to: http://www.orioncaraudio.com/Products/Subwoofers/Default.aspx

Want to know more about Syndicate Automotive Concepts?
Visit: www.syndicateauto.com

Voltage, Impedance, and Peak Music Power Test Details:



The following is a summary of the test results with voltages, impedances, and peak music power.

The JL was tested at 94.5 V RMS Peak Music Power or 2976.75 W Peak Music Power at 3 ohms voice coil resistance.  The W7 is only available in 3 Ohm.

The music track used for testing is approximately 3 minutes long and is repeated throughout the test cycle.  Over half of the 3 minute track is below 1000 W and there are six peaks that are above 90 V and near 3000 W peak music power.

3000 W into 3 ohms = 94.87V 3500 W into 3 ohms = 102.47 V 4500 W into 4 ohms = 134.16 V
3000 W into 4 ohms = 109.54 V 3500 W into 4 ohms = 118.32 V 4500 W into 8 ohms = 189.74 V
3000 W into 8 ohms = 154.92 V 3500 W into 8 ohms = 167.33 V  

ORION HCCA
The HCCA passed all other competitors and failed when the power was raised to 6050 W into 8 ohms = 220 V
KICKER SoloX
Kicker passed at 2997.56 W 1 hour
Kicker failed at 3499.91 W  12 min
1 hr 12 min total play time
 Kicker continued to play even though it was knocking and sounded terrible as we raised the power and stopped at    4502.41 W
MTX Thunder
MTX passed at 2983.78 W 1 hour
MTX failed at 3494.8 W 5 min
1 hr 5 min total play time
JL AUDIO W7
JL failed at 3072 W 7 min
ROCKFORD FOSGATE Power
Rockford failed at 2983.78 W 3 min
CERWIN-VEGA Stroker
Cerwin Vega failed at 2983.78 W 5 min

 

 

 
VISTA, CA - 1/14/2008
Directed Electronics Becomes Exclusive Mobile Audio Partner With the UFC(R)...
VISTA, CA - 1/16/2008
NOW SHIPPING – Affordable ORION™ COBALT® Speakers, Amps, and Subs
Product Support
 
arrow Install & User Guides
arrow WiringPro Sub Wiring
arrow Sub Enclosure Size Guide
arrow Orion User Forum
arrow Orion Knowledge Library
  cap
   
 

Orion Forum